Copyright Puck to the Head
I’m a little disappointed to see such an outcry over a TV theme song for professional [Facebook link] sports. Sure, it’s something everyone is familiar with, but it’s not like it’s Happy Birthday. (That was a joke, because of course that song too is mired in copyright muck thanks to greedy Disney Time-Warner-AOL [Thank you Stephen for the correction.].) There are a few more important controversies that required broad based public outcry, but since this is a topic that even a 12 year old can get passionate about, it fits into Internet activism much better than Cadscam does.
I’m a little torn. While it’s good that the artist who composed the HNIC Theme Song has been well compensated for her creation, where should her right to capitalize on the song end? After a set number of years, or until she passes from the earth? There are good arguments for either, but for arguments sake I’d say after about 40 years of making money from one creation, perhaps it’s time to create a new golden goose. Not knowing her other work, I won’t call her a one hit wonder, but clearly her name isn’t ingrained into the average Canadian’s pop-consciousness like Oscar Peterson or Avril Lavigne.
So I think after most of a lifetime has passed, that the HNIC theme song should be in the public domain, and neither the CBC nor any one of us reading (or writing my words) should have to pay to publicly sing or broadcast the music.
Is CBC nuts for dropping it? Yes. But I have to agree with them that they were justified in using the distinctive theme in overseas broadcasts. The distinction when the theme is in theory available on the WWW, is outdated anyway. Claman killed, or at least sat on, her golden goose. Both sides should have handled the matter with more grace. CBC should have asked for permission, and Claman should have granted it at no charge.
This story is also a trap for the goons who would see CBC torn down for spending too much taxpayer money. Why should the public broadcaster pay for a theme song when they could save hundreds of dollars every broadcast by going with a different theme provider?
–
You can Digg this post by Nunc Scio. Hockey nut Miss 604 of course writes about this too.
