The Sexy Isotope Issue
OK, who leaves behind a digital recorder that was left on by accident? The same person who leaves behind Secret documents, that’s who. Yeeeesh.
And bankers can take it up the… yeah.
“Neither Ms. MacDonnell nor the minister knew the conversations was being recorded. … It (tape recorder) was turned on inadvertently in the bag she was travelling with.”
But Moir ruled the five-hour and 16 minute recording should be public.
“It is wrong to deprive the press, and the public it serves, of remarks made privately but not confidentially in the sense of trade secrets,” he said.
The judge said the minister’s statement on the medical isotopes is important for the public to know and outweighs any potential harm to the reputation of MacDonnell.
“The issue of the political oversight of Canada’s medical isotope system is literally a matter of life and death for cancer patients. It is a matter of intense public interest,” he said.
“The handling of this issue by the government and the cabinet ministers is a matter of immediate public and political interest.”
In court documents, Chronicle Herald reporter Stephen Maher says he let MacDonnell know he had the device – which was found in a press gallery washroom – but she never picked it up from his offices on Parliament Hill.
It wasn’t until June 4 that the newspaper decided to listen to the tape, a day after MacDonnell resigned over a gaffe involving sensitive documents.
The judge said he “doubted” criminal laws preventing interception of private conversations would apply to the case because the recording was left in a public place.
CBC has more.









@hotmail.com





![[EFC Blue Ribbon - Free Speech Online]](http://www.efc.ca/images/efcfreet.gif)